Commercial

Research and Rehabilitation

Fort Belvoir Community Hospital takes a holistic and analytical approach to healthcare design.

9 MIN READ

A healing garden at the Fort Belvoir Community Hospital, a tree-lined facility in Virginia less than 20 miles south of Washington, D.C., bears little resemblance to the sterile, airless courtyards of other hospitals. With geometric paving patterns, varied plantings, and zen-garden-like pebble paths, this is just one of several distinct areas of the new facility that are designed to blur the lines between building and nature.

The almost-1.3-million-square-foot hospital was developed in response to the 2005 Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) Commission Report and the Defense Base Closure and Realignment Act of 1990. These necessitated the closure of the Walter Reed Army Medical Center, whose capabilities were then split between the National Naval Medical Center in Bethesda, Md., and Fort Belvoir. The new facility at Fort Belvoir, completed last summer, has 120 beds and is roughly four times the size of the DeWitt Army Community Hospital, the former medical facility on site. Because of its immensity, reducing the facility’s environmental impact was a goal from the outset, with the project on track for LEED Gold certification.

Designed by HDR in a joint venture with Fairfax, Va.–based Dewberry, the hospital is the first military hospital in the country to combine evidence-based design (EBD) and a sustainable return on investment (SROI) analysis. In this case, the EBD process examined how elements of the physical environment—elements chosen by the project designers—affect building inhabitants or patient outcomes, according to Jeff Getty, the project’s lead architectural designer and a senior vice president at HDR. The building design is based on scientific research and takes a more holistic approach than traditional medical design, he says.

The SROI analysis takes into account relevant social, economic, and environmental effects, both immediate and long-term, of the project’s energy- and water-conservation measures. “It provides measurable metrics for sustainable features and helps to justify our decisions,” Getty says. This, coupled with the EBD research, helped the team to choose elements that would achieve a variety of desired results, such as reductions in utility bills or air-pollutant emissions.

“The business of evidence-based design was interwoven with our aspirations for sustainability features,” Getty says. “For example, the mechanical filtration of air [in portions of the building] is done with HEPA filtration. It cleanses the air of contagions that imperil patients in particular. That is one of the things that is shown by research to have negative impacts on patient outcomes.”

Treatment of the site, which previously had been a nine-hole golf course, was particularly important, Getty says. The team preserved or restored 62 percent of the natural environment with native and adaptive plants and installed curbless parking, which naturally drains water into bioretention areas. Bioswales on either side of the building absorb stormwater and surface drainage. Getty says that the team planted two trees for every one removed during construction.

Rather than be one colossal monolith, the building is divided into five distinct wings, graduated in height from the six-story main building down to a pair of two-floor buildings. “The concept of the building was derived from the idea of trying to preserve a single stand of old trees,” Getty says, “so we kind of wrapped the building around that.” Getty calls the building “crenellated,” with walls and edges that cut in and out to offer more views and opportunities for daylight.

Several elements that came out of the EBD process will assist hospital staff. Reducing hospital-acquired infections through the installation of easily accessible hand-washing sinks in patient and exam rooms is a major EBD element. At Fort Belvoir, these spaces include floor tiling that directs staff to these stations. Most inpatient rooms also have a patient lift to limit hospital-staff injuries, a common problem in hospitals.

“Our staff members love the new hospital and are awestruck the moment they see the facility,” says Army Col. Alan B. Shoupe, the hospital’s deputy commander for healthcare operations and strategic planning. “Our staff commonly talks about how easy it is to get around the facility, how the technology that is in place helps them complete their jobs more quickly, and how the facility helps them provide safe, quality, compassionate care to patients.”

The most distinctive building feature may be the swooping roofs that channel rainwater into underground cisterns where it is kept for reuse in irrigation on site. (“The swoops also pay homage to Fort Belvoir’s large bald eagle population,” Shoupe says.) Getty asserts that this system, paired with the condensation saved from the HVAC system, will save the facility 1.6 million gallons of potable water every year over a comparable building. A vegetated roof, visible from patient rooms, also captures stormwater and reduces the heat-island effect.

Mechanical and lighting systems are designed to be as energy efficient as possible, including a heat-recovery chiller system. The result of HDR’s green strategy is an estimated 27 percent energy reduction, a savings of nearly $500,000 on annual energy costs, and an estimated savings of 4,000 tons in CO2 emissions—all compared to a standard-design hospital, according to Getty.

Finally, the team created a series of reflective and distinct garden spaces around the hospital, each developed for a particular constituency—soldiers, children, chapel visitors, and others. “Indoor air quality, views to the outside, access to nature—these all provide positive psychological benefits, but go hand in hand with sustainability,” Getty says. “Our goal was to get this whole building closer to the landscape.”

Kim A. O’Connell writes about historic preservation and sustainable design from Arlington, Va.

FORT BELVOIR COMMUNITY HOSPITAL

Green Team

Architect, electrical engineer, green specifications, interior designer, life-cycle cost analysis and sustainable return on investment services, lighting designer, structural engineer: HDR, hdrinc.com— Jimmy Bates, Dave Bechtol, Barbara Dellinger, Jeff Getty, Stephane Larocque, Jordi Mack, Bruce Maine, Matt Muhlenkamp, Michael Paczak, Erin Viviani
Civil engineer: Dewberry, dewberry.com—Tim Cullieton
Client, geotechnical engineer: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, www.usace.army.mil—David Tucker (mechanical engineer)Construction manager: Gilbane, gilbaneco.com—Vic Mudryk
General contractor: Turner/Gilbane Joint Venture
Landscape architect: Lee and Associates, leeandassociatesinc.com—Jeff Lee
Mechanical engineer, project manager: Dewberry—Mark Heinrich; HDR—Bill Hoffman, Ted Zsirai
Project managers: Dewberry—Tom Christensen; HDR—Terry Williams
Sustainable-design project manager: Gilbane—Janice Rogers; HDR—Lidia Berger

MATERIALS

Acoustical system, ceilings: Armstrong, armstrong.com
Adhesives: BASF, basf.com; Forbo, forbo.com; Garner Gibson, gardner-gibson.com; Interface Flor, interfaceflor.com; Nora, nora.com; PPG Industries, ppg.com; Roppe, roppe.com; Tandus, tandus.com; Taylor, wftaylor.com; Teknoflor, teknoflor.com; Terrazzo & Marble Supply, tmsupply.com
Appliances: Continental Refrigerator, continentalrefrigerator.com; Jenn-Air, jennair.com; Lancer, lancercorp.com; Mortech, mortechmfg.com; Maquet Getinge, getinge.com; Whirlpool, whirlpool.com
Building-management systems and services: Delta Controls, deltacontrols.com
Carpet: Constantine Carpet, constantine-carpet.com; Forbo Flooring, forbo-flooring.com; Interface Flor; Monticello, monticellofloors.com
Cladding: Metal Sales & Service, metalwerksusa.com; Moeding, moeding.de; Reynobond, alcoa.com
Coatings and sealants: Carboline, carboline.com; Coronado Industrial Coating, coronadopaint.com; Gator Chemicals, gatorchemical.com; International Paints; Johnson Diversey, johnsondiversey.com; Rust-Oleum, rustoleum.com; Sika, usa.sika.com
Concrete, masonry and stone: Champlain Stone, champlainstone.com; Charles Luck Stone Center, charlesluck.com; Chippewa Stone, chippewastone.com; Cold Spring Granite, coldspringgranite.com; Ernest Maier, emcoblock.com; Hagerstown Block Co., hagerstownblock.com; Lafarge, lafarge.com; Lehigh Heidelberg Cement Group, lehighcement.com; Maine Millstones, mainemillstones.com; The Minimalist Group, beachpebbles.com; North Carolina Granite Corp., www.ncgranite.com; Palmetto Brick Co., palmettobrick.com; Quikrete Co., www.quikrete.com; Western Precast Concrete, westernprecast.com; York Building Products Co., yorkbuilding.com
Curtainwalls: Kawneer North America, kawneer.com; Oldcastle BuildingEnvelope, oldcastlebe.com
Fabrics: Forbo, forbo.com
Flooring: Armstrong; Daltile, daltile.com; Dinoflex Group, dinoflex.com; Forbo, forbo.com; Grassi Pietre, grassipietre.it; James Halstead, jameshalstead.com; National Metal Shapes, nationalmetalshapes.com; Mondo, mondousa.com; Nora, nora.com; Pietra Piasentina, consorziopietrapiasentina.it; Terrrazzo and Marble Supply, tmsupply.com
Furniture: Herman Miller, hermanmiller.com; Knoll, knoll.com; National Office Furniture, nationalofficefurniture.com; Nucraft, nucraft.com; Steelcase, steelcase.com
Glass: Oldcastle BuildingEnvelope; TGP, fireglass.com
HVAC: ABB, abb.com; ETL, etlairconditioning.co.uk; Lenze AC Tech, actech.com; Soler & Pafau, solerpalau-usa.com
Insulation: DOW, building.dow.com; Guardian, guardianbp.com; Johns Manville, jm.com; Roxul, roxul.com
Lighting-control systems: Cooper Industries, cooperindustries.com; Federated Lighting, federatedlighting.com; Honeywell, honeywell.com; Lighting Control and Design, lightingcontrols.com; Omron Global, omron.com; Sensor Switch, sensorswitch.com
Lighting: Acuity Brands, acuitybrands.com; BEGA, bega-us.com; Cooper Lighting; Flight Light, flightlight.com; Focal Point, focalpointlights.com; General Electric, ge.com; Gotham, gothamlighting.com; GVA Lighting, gvalighting.com; Kurt Versen, kurtversen.com; Ledalite, ledalite.com; Lighting Services, lightingservicesinc.com; Light Wild, lightwild.com; Lithonia Lighting, lithonia.com; Louis Poulsen, louispoulsen.com; Manning Lighting, manningltg.com; NDL Electrical, ndle.co.uk; Peachtree Lighting, peachtreelighting.com; Peerless Lighting, peerless-lighting.com; Philips, usa.lighting.philips.com; Q-Tran, q-tran.com; SPI Lighting, spilighting.com; Targetti Poulsen, targettipoulsen.com; UL, ul.com; Winona Lighting, winonalighting.com
Metal: Atlas Tube, atlastube.com; Banker Steel, bankersteel.com; Berlin Steel, berlinsteel.com; Can Art, canart.com; CMC, cmc.com; Construction Specialties, c-sgroup.com; Dri-Design, dri-design.com; Elmdor/Stoneman, elmdorstoneman.com; Gerdau Ameristeel, gerdau.com; Infasco; Georgia Pacific, gp.com; Keymark Corp., keymarkcorp.com; LIW Ironworks, liwironworks.com; Marinoware, marinoware.com; Mercegaglia, marcegaglia-usa.com; New Millennium, newmill.com; Outo Kumpu, outokumpu.com; Pittcon Industries, pittconindustries.com
Paints and finishes: Benjamin Moore, benjaminmoore.com; DuPont Industrial Coatings, pc.dupont.com; McCormick Paint, mccormickpaints.com; PPG Industries
Pavers: Hanover Architectural, hanoverpavers.com; Stepstone, stepstoneinc.com
Plumbing and water systems: ABS Pumps, absgroupusa.com; Crestline Plastic Pipe, crestline.com; Hanson Pipe, hansonpipeandprecast.com; Hunter Industries, hunterindustries.com; King Fisher, kingfisherinc.com; Quality Erectors, qec-inc.com; RB Wagner, rbwagner.com; Rainbird, rainbird.com; United States Pipe, uspipe.com; Watertronics, watertronics.com; Ryerson, ryerson.com
Roofing: Alcoa, alcoa.com; Ecosurfaces, ecosurfaces.com; Emory Knoll Farms, greenroofplants.com; GAF Materials, gaf.com
Signage: Evonik, acrylite.net; Kommerling USA, kommerlingusa.com; Nova Polymers, novapolymers.com; Yarde, yarde.com
Site and landscape products: Bentwood Nursery, bentwoodnursery.com; Chesterfield Farms; Collier Metal Specialties, colmet.com; Flower City Nurseries; Hopewell Nursery, hopewellnursery.com; Hydrotech, hydrotechusa.com; MJ Fitzgerald Nursery; Pennington Seed, penningtonseed.com; Roseland Nursery, roselandroses.com
Structural systems: American Infrastructure, americaninfrastructure.com; Banker Steel, bankersteel.com; CMC, cmc.com; Gerdau Ameristeel, gerdau.com; LIW Ironworks, liwironworks.com; New Millennium, newmill.com; Steel Dynamics, steeldynamics.com
Wallcoverings: Carnegie Fabrics, carnegiefabrics.com; Dream Scape, dreamscapedirect.com; Omnova, omnova.com
Walls: Clark Dietrich Building Systems, clarkdietrich.com; Henry Co., henry.com; Karnak Corp., karnakcorp.com; MarinoWare, marinoware.com; National Gypsum, nationalgypsum.com; Umicore, umicore.com; Grace, grace.com
Windows and doors: Algoma, algomahardwoods.com; Ceco Door, cecodoor.com; Curries Door, curries.com; Loewen, loewen.com; Oldcastle BuildingEnvelope; Overhead Door, overheaddoor.com; Stanley Access Technologies, stanleyaccess.com; TGP

By the Numbers

Building gross floor area: 2,281,112 gross square feet
Number of permanent occupants and visitors: 2,795 staff working three shifts per day; 99 inpatients at any time; 1,210 outpatients and visitors per day
Percent of the building that can be ventilated or cooled with operable windows: Zero
Total water used (gallons per year): 11,825,703
Total energy used (kBtu per square foot per year): 218.58
Percent total energy savings: 15.9% cost savings, 27.6% regulated MBtu savings
LEED rating: Silver, NC v.2.2 anticipated; Tracking for Gold, NC v2.2
Total project cost: $747 million (estimated)
Data is based on LEED design case study, not post-occupancy data, and was provided by HDR.

About the Author

Upcoming Events

  • Introduction to Winding Drum Panoramic Home Elevators

    Live CEU Webinar

    Register Now
  • Beyond the Numbers: How Benchmarking is Driving Smarter Decisions in Architecture Firms

    Live CEU Webinar

    Register Now
  • Future Place

    Irving, TX

    Register Now